Monday, 5 September 2011

A parallel universe

That confirms it; I am definitely living in a parallel universe. As most ordinary schools went about their business of starting the new school term in the usual orderly way a newspaper headline shouted ‘schools failing on safety’. This was their interpretation of an Ofsted report which had stated that ‘almost all schools now take a careful and responsible approach to their safeguarding arrangements’ and that only 2% were inadequate in this respect. And let's not make the mistake of blaming it entirely on the media. Ofsted caused the problem in the first place by turning the dictionary definition of satisfactory on its head by stating that ‘safeguarding arrangements in 21% of schools were only satisfactory overall, indicating the need for considerable improvement’
At the same time Michael Gove's speech at the Durand Academy was widely reported. One paper gleefully stated: ‘At last teacher is back in charge! Tories pledge to end classroom chaos....’ The opportunity for rational discussion about the points he had made was drowned out by the noise.
All of this had come at the end of a week which had been dominated by ill-informed party political posturing about the relative merits or otherwise of the so-called ‘academic’ subjects as defined in the English Baccalaureate. Once again any reasoned discussion about the kind of curriculum young people in 21st century need was shouted down.
These and an almost constant barrage of similar examples highlight the real challenge our profession faces at the moment.
I have been warning ministers and their advisers for some considerable time about the messages they are repeatedly sending out about our education service which not only plays into tabloid headlines but most significantly sends out a deeply damaging message to young people that they are not being served by their schools. Messages such as these:
·         behaviour is extremely poor and needs to be sorted out by government,  army officers or male teachers.
·         truancy is rife
·         the curriculum is not fit for purpose
·         exams have been dumbed down
·         the quality of teachers being recruited into the profession is not good enough
·         teacher training is based on ‘outdated theory’ rather than best practice
·         almost every other country has a better education system than ours.
I wonder whether those who make such statements somehow think that young people do not hear these messages. Having taught in and led schools for more than 30 years I know exactly how acutely tuned the antennae of young people are. They know exactly what is being said and these kinds of messages make the work of teachers and school leaders unnecessarily difficult.
And critically these messages also prevent us from having the level of debate we really need in our quest to improve the education service which is the bread and butter of our professional territory. No school leader I have ever met believes that our education service is perfect. In fact they are one of the most self-critical groups of professionals I have ever come across whose confidence is constantly being undermined by these utterances. Talk of a high status profession sounds deeply hollow in the context of the barrage of denigration we face.
And the even greater danger is therefore that the real ‘dumbing down’ is of the professional debate that needs to take place.
During the last few weeks significant numbers of young people have had the opportunity to explain their perspective on these issues in the media in the aftermath of the riots. The message they have been giving us is that they need hope. They hear about the economic context, they know that jobs are few and far between , they know that University places are under great demand and that the new fee regime which they perceive as a deterrent is being introduced, they see the reductions in services that affect their lives including youth facilities, careers advice and EMA as schools and colleges try harder than ever to motivate them to aspire towards greater things. In addition many are being told that the curriculum that interests them is the wrong one and that the only ones that matter are those that are irrelevant to their specific needs and led them to being disengaged in the first place.
We ignore these messages at our peril. English society faces some unprecedented challenges which can only be addressed together.  Any school or college leader will tell you how important the establishment of a positive ethos is to the success of their institution. We need an ethos in our society which gives our young people the confidence to complete their education with hope, aspiration and self-belief. 
Without that our profession will have to get used to remaining in a parallel universe.

Wednesday, 25 May 2011

Social mobility - I rest my case!

Alan Milburn's well attended Tribal lecture was a strange affair. It started with a message which chimes loudly with school and college leaders for whom the improvement of social mobility is at the heart of their raison d’être. He tracked the changes from a period starting in the 50s where social hope underpinned a commitment by the state to move away from a culture of ‘birth not worth’ to a society decades later which is more ossified and reflects greater social resentment. He talked of the progress the last government made to raise the glass ceiling recognising that there is much to do and cited the fact that three out of four judges, half of civil servants and one in three parliamentarians were educated privately. He described the valuable work of the Social Mobility and Child Poverty commission which will rigorously and independently assess the impact of what any government is doing on the creation of a fairer society in which people from all backgrounds have equal chances of progression. So far so good until he started talking about schools.......
 For a while I was on board as he emphasised the importance of employability skills as a key and gave some strong messages to the coalition about the parlous state of careers guidance and the fact that we cannot afford not to invest in education. However, then came the proposed solutions:
Another regime of targets for schools, judging them on outcomes such as destinations of pupils.
National programmes to raise aspirations because “there aren't enough good schools”. The language of failing schools came to the fore.
And then, quite bizarrely, a proposal for parents to be ‘empowered’ to choose ‘good’ schools. Parents of children who attend ‘failing’ schools would be given a voucher to the value of one half times the per pupil funding which they could take to another school with their children.
As you can imagine a lively discussion ensued.
I continue to despair as schools are presented as the problem rather than the solution. Where are these leaders who do not want young people to succeed – who will only ‘shape up’ with yet more threats and accountability measures in a system which must be the most monitored in the world? We know the problems are so much more complex than that.
But most importantly we all know that proposals such as this would simply not work. Pupils with parents who know their way round the system would be channelled away from the schools in challenging areas to schools in leafy suburbs which would thrive on the additional funding. The remaining pupils in other schools would be condemned to education in a poorly funded environment undergoing a slow process of attrition. The gap would widen as they missed out on their only chances.
In the discussion an example was given of a school which had  apparently been ‘failing’  for many years. Why didn't the local authority close the school we asked? Because no politicians will close schools because it would lose votes.
Commitment to improving social mobility?  I rest my case.

Monday, 9 May 2011

Are we entering into a new era of cooperation between employers and educators?

Anyone  reading the media coverage of the latest CBI Education and Skills Survey would have felt a strong sense of déjà vu. The usual depressing story – school leavers lack the skills they need etc. etc. Interested in hearing the truth I went to the launch with some trepidation only to discover a classic ‘cup half empty’ story.
First of all my questions about what the definition of  a school leaver– a 16 year old with or without GCSEs, an 18 year old A Level leaver a university graduate all or some? – all remain unanswered. There is a real danger in generalisations of this kind which undermine the validity of any survey.  Nevertheless as I looked at the results it became abundantly clear that they actually confirmed a far more positive picture and a high level of consensus between employers and  school and college leaders. Here are some headlines:
68% of employers are satisfied with school and college leavers’ teamworking skills, 65% with their positive attitude to work, 64% with their basic numeracy skills, 59% with their basic literacy skills. Ironically one of the lowest  scores was 45% satisfaction with their self management skills. This includes punctuality – an irony which did not escape some of those present who were still waiting for the minister an hour after his scheduled slot. All of this demonstrates a great deal of good news, none of which was reported, yet we all recognise that we all need to work together to improve things further.
An interesting statistic was that 64% do not believe that the quality of careers advice is good enough  but a very encouraging 54% are willing to do more to support schools in delivering this. This is a great relief in the light of the continuing complete lack of progress in taking the promised All Age Advisory Service forward or even deciding what it will look like.
The DfE response was a highly predictable restatement of its commitment to the English Baccalaureate and increasing emphasis on GCSE English and Maths. This missed the point entirely as the speakers representing major employers highlighted the key issues:
Employability skills should be embedded in the national curriculum and certainly not ignored. Functional skills in literacy and numeracy should be taught and assessed – GCSE is not necessarily the answer. Problem solving skills are the least developed and need to be a priority. None of these should be taught separately – they should be integral to the teaching of all subjects. We need to continue to emphasise stem subjects. All of this sounded to me like a resounding endorsement of the kind of priorities ASCL has highlighted in making the case for a better baccalaureate
Most encouragingly employers said that they do not want to stand on the sidelines and complain. Some apt quotations from a report written in 1899 bemoaning the way young people are equipped for the world of commerce reminded the audience that this is not exactly a new problem. The need to redefine what we mean by employability skills has never been greater. ASCL is engaged in a constructive dialogue with CBI about these skills and I know from firsthand experience working with the Education Employer Taskforce that some sterling work is going on there too.
Although I was unable to wait for the minister I left feeling a lot less depressed than teachers and school leaders will have felt when reading the morning papers.

Thursday, 14 April 2011

Protecting freedom or a Luddite reaction?


The Protection of Freedoms Bill now going through Parliament dedicates a chapter to biometric systems in schools and colleges. If it goes through unaltered, which is looking increasingly likely, it could cost the education system between £20 and £45 million a year. What’s worse, the changes are a knee-jerk reaction to unfounded protests from by children’s and civil rights groups, not legitimate concerns raised by parents.  

The definition of biometrics in the legislation means that the legislation will extend to all digital photographs used for identification purpose, as well as smart cards with student photos and CCTV. This means will be even more difficult for schools and colleges to use CCTV to help maintain discipline and order, in direct contrast to the government’s pledge to support schools in reducing bad behaviour.

The new legislation will require the written permission of both parents, plus any other person with parental responsibility for a child, in order to use biometric systems, including finger recognition, iris scanning and digital images. The only exceptions are if one of the parents cannot be found or lacks capacity (in a legal sense) to make the decision, or where it would not be in the child’s interest to allow the parent to know his/her whereabouts (as with an abusive parent). Consent can be withdrawn at any time.

We completely agree that parents should have a say in whether their children take part in biometric systems in schools and they should have the right to opt out of if they have concerns or are opposed in principle. However, if the bill goes through, the hoops that schools and colleges will need to go through to use these systems will be completely disproportional.

For some pupils this could involve three or even four adults, some of whom refuse to cooperate either with the school or another estranged parent. In almost all other aspects of school life, parents either chose to opt out or one parent signs on behalf of the family unit. Either of these options would ease the administrative and financial burden on schools and colleges considerably.

What is particularly worrying is that the Parliamentary committee scrutinising the bill has only called for oral evidence from children’s and civil liberties campaigners even though ASCL and others have submitted detailed written evidence pointing out that the vast majority of parents do not have an issue with the technology.

About 30 per cent of secondary schools use biometrics systems for access, libraries or catering. These systems are not susceptible to children losing smart cards or key fobs and their access rights cannot be stolen. They enable parents to ensure that children spend money on what parents have given it for and can make schools more safe and secure places.  Evidence shows that when parents have been made aware of how the system works and what kind of data it collects, 99.8 per cent have taken up the system. This is a Luddite reaction and a huge backward step.

ASCL’s full evidence to the bill committee is at www.ascl.org.uk/consultations

Thursday, 10 February 2011

Blaming schools and colleges for the effects of tuition fees is a smoke screen


As the level of fees to be charged by England's top universities  has been announced and the government’s panic reaction has been the threat of yet more targets, there has been a suggestion from some quarters that schools and colleges will be to blame if the number of students applying to university from poorer backgrounds drops once tuition fees increase. Pointing the blame at schools is a smoke screen that masks the real issue -many young people will be put off by the thought of having to pay back tens of thousands of pounds once they start working. Parents who are neither the lowest nor high earners will understandably warn their sons and daughters against taking on significant debts. Those are the young people who won’t be eligible for grants or scholarships or free school meals, but will still find it a hardship to pay for living expenses, never mind paying back huge chunks of money when they graduate.

Schools and colleges have put a tremendous amount of effort into raising aspirations of students who have the ability but possibly not the confidence to aim for a university degree. When the A Level results were published last summer we saw an increase in the numbers of young people who have clearly chosen their subjects with the labour market in mind. Results continue to improve with students working harder than ever to gain top grades. This has been supported by a raft of initiatives to help young people stay in education and aspire to university – not just education maintenance allowance but programmes like Aim Higher – which have made a real difference to students’ aspirations. One by one these initiatives have lost their funding and schools have been left high and dry when trying to maintain this important provision. They are trying hard to do this but it is an uphill struggle in which not all will succeed.

The other element to consider is high quality careers advice and guidance. The Connexions service which used to provide this is being dismantled in many areas. The government is planning an all-age careers service, a concept which ASCL fully supports, but at the moment the detail of how this will operate or be funded is alarmingly absent. Once again the government has put the cart before the horse, dismantling one structure before it has thought through how it will pick up the pieces. Schools and colleges are completely in the dark about how this will operate in practice.

Schools and colleges will continue to do all they can to raise aspirations, but the bottom line is that they can’t do it in a vacuum. No matter how good their grades are and how well they are coached to pass an Oxbridge entrance exam, if they have to find an additional £40 or £50k for the privilege, many will say no.

Sunday, 5 December 2010

The Baccalaureate that has put performance targets back on the agenda.

The English Baccalaureate is attracting more comments from ASCL members than any other aspect of the White Paper. Most of these relate to the creation of a new ‘retrospective performance indicator’ which in January 2011 will judge schools against a measure they had no inkling of until very recently and have had no opportunity to work towards. There is already strong evidence that this performance indicator has begun to drive the curriculum in exactly the way previous ones have done. Although the coalition has criticised this kind of target culture it is now going down exactly the same route.
School leaders therefore have the choice of responding in one of two ways: Some are saying that, in an age of autonomy, it is up to them to decide how to shape their curriculum. They highlight the tension between the promised new freedoms and this very specific level of prescription albeit through the accountability system rather than regulation. These school leaders will consider the English Bac on its merits, decide whether or not to implement it and, if so, to which cohort. If they decide against it they will be confident to allow their schools to be judged against other performance indicators. Others feel they have no option other than to change their options columns straight away in order to offer this to students.  Many of these are national challenge schools which have already  tasted the consequences of ‘floor targets’ and the public naming and shaming that accompanied the last set. You can understand why.  As there will not have been an opportunity to make such changes in the context of a structured review of their curriculum this will simply be a reaction to the new performance indicator.
Views about the merits of the Bac as a curriculum model vary. Many ASCL members would   support the idea of a basic and rounded academic curriculum and therefore  believe that it is a worthwhile measure for at least some of their students. Levelling the playing field of opportunity for students from deprived backgrounds to give them a chance  to gain  qualifications which will enable them to access the best universities is certainly a worthy aim.  Many strongly support the idea of encouraging modern foreign languages and few disagree with the aim of aiming to gain GCSEs in English , Maths and Science for as many as possible. Few believe that the inclusion of Biblical Hebrew, Ancient Greek and Latin as a part of this certificate instead of a Modern Language makes any sense at all.
Many others (and I suspect a majority) are deeply concerned about the effects of this on the rest of the curriculum, the arts, the other humanities, technological subjects and PE. There is considerable anger and consternation that RS is not included as a humanity. Nearly all are horrified at the silence of the White Paper on any aspect of practical learning and employability skills. They feel that there is a real risk of narrowing the curriculum for the most able and possibly quite a few others.  There are also serious staffing implications in terms of existing staff who will no longer have the opportunity to teach their specialism to GCSE and in terms of teacher supply if there is a sudden demand for teachers of the English Bac subjects.      
Whatever the ‘Bac’ is it is not a Baccalaureate in the true sense. As the DfE statement of intent admits it is not even a qualification. I am far from convinced  that ad hoc changes to performance tables are the best way to implement a 21st century curriculum which is fit to raise our standing in the international stakes.